Date: 14 Sep 2015, Economics and Finance
Question setter: John Karslake

China GDP

Will China announce a Gross Domestic Product (GDP) Annual Growth Rate of 6.9% or above for its third quarter 2015?


Response:


Answer: Yes
Confidence level: 0%
Mean confidence level (all requests): 33.00%

Justification:
The subscriber's answer appears here. This should be up to 200 words of rationale for the YES / NO answer and will form part of a portfolio of answers to be assessed by a prospective employer.

Employers are unlikely to read an entire portfolio but will pick one or two question topics that may interest them or challenge the subscriber.

Mettletest provides links and resources to help subscribers to form opinions and answer questions without spending too much time.

Expert answers are shown below so you can see how they approach Mettletest.

Outcome: Yes
Score: 0
Mean score (all respondents): -33.00

Expert opinion:


Answer: No

Selected Expert Answer from Mettletest Panellist:
OXFORD ANALYTICA:
We think that it will be around 7% (in the 6.5% - 7.5% range)
China's GDP figures are among the most closely watched economic data in the world. Yet the media and researchers question their reliability, particularly now that growth is slowing, fearing that the political imperative of demonstrating economic competence will push the leadership to 'massage' the figures. In fact, China's statistical system is under intense pressure to produce reliable data, and numerous innovations have been undertaken to upgrade it.
What next
Chinese economic data have many weaknesses, but any political influence on national GDP data is probably indirect and very rare. As growth stabilizes around a long-term trend, measuring the economy will become easier and more accurate.
Subsidiary Impacts
Political influence on economic data is primarily at the provincial and local levels.
• Difficulties in compiling accurate data imply some flexibility for the NBS in determining the values of short-run indicators.
• Quinquennial revisions based on economic censuses will continue to provide the most reliable data.

Answer: No

Selected Expert Answer from Mettletest Panel:
Announcements from the Chinese government and recent data indicate that growth rates are slowing and that the likelihood is that Jul-Sep GDP will undershoot the 7% previously forecast. China is pre-empting this news with proposals for growth, including the part-privitisation of state enterprises. This is after repeated cuts in interest rates and the relaxation of banks' reserve requirements to stimulate the economy. The stock market has suffered heavy falls, in the wake of Yuan devaluation, another indication of official concern that the pace is slowing. There have been disappointing figures on fixed-asset investment and August factory output, while some experienced commentators point to low electricity usage as a sure indicator that all is not well. Continued falling car sale confirm this. However, I do not believe we are in negative territory, as some theorists do. Otherwise I would not expect officials to put their necks on the line with relatively upbeat statements. Premier Li Keqiang declated last week that the economy is still moving positively. So, under 6.9%, but not that much under, I reckon.


Outcome: Yes

Comment on outcome from Mettletest Panellist:
Expectations have been confounded - China's 3rd quarter GDP DID come in at 6.9%. A recent Bloomberg poll had the consensus at only 6.7%. It appears that the Chinese services sector compensated for the weakness in manufacturing and property. The slowdown in the latter two was correctly identified by clever analysis of electricity use and building but few economists realised how strong the emerging services sector has become.
Overall, there is still concern at how growth can be sustained in the future. These GDP figures show the weakest growth since 2009. Further slowdown is predicted in the coming years, even if this is the worst in the short-term. Many commentators think the official statistics are overstated and that real growth is weaker.